C COMICS (Part 6)

Title page of Joe Brainard and Robert Creeley’s “Class of ’47”
In 1973, Joe Brainard collaborated on a single comic with the poet Robert Creeley. Not part of Brainard’s immediate New York circle of poet friends, Creeley was however one of the most beloved non-mainstream poets of his time.
Creeley, born in 1926, entered Harvard University in 1943, leaving the following year to enlist as an ambulance driver in Burma during World War II. Brainard, who had earned a scholarship to the Dayton Art Institute in 1960, left about a month later for New York City to make his living as an artist.
Documentation describing Brainard and Creeley’s process creating “Class of ’47,” which was originally published in a limited edition by Bouwerie Editions in 1973 and then republished in Chain 8: Comics, has not yet surfaced.
Whether or not Creeley supplied the text first—which is my own best guess—the comic itself is clearly a satire on the kinds of posturing one finds in alumni newsletters. On its most basic level, given that both Creeley and Brainard were drop-outs, the comic becomes a kind of “there but for the grace of God go I.”

The text itself is made up of sentences most likely lifted from Harvard’s alumni magazine, Harvard Monthly. Brainard supplies iconic imagery—mostly of either popular characters from comics or, a bit later on, comics-inspired icons used in advertising for Laundromats and drycleaners, gas stations, and so on.

Brainard repeatedly employs trompe-l'œil tears in the page through which some of these characters emerge. The effect is especially funny, contrasting the excited bursts of enthusiastic cartoons with the pompous alumni language—which is almost heartbreakingly mundane in its content. The Mickey Mouse-King of Spades character is particularly pointed—one thinks not only of the derogatory use of “mickey mouse” as descriptor, but of Alice in Wonderland’s “You’re nothing but a pack of cards!”
The inevitable “I’m working on a novel,” which follows this, is particularly devastating.

One of Brainard’s last comics—Brainard stopped producing art of any kind in the early to mid-1980s—“Class of ’47” includes many of Brainard’s signature traits: the appropriation of popular culture iconography (including his beloved Nancy, who appears on the second to last page), the use of arrows to highlight things he finds particularly funny (including his own “accidental” ink smudges); and page layouts that show him playing with the traditional function of the panel to delineate specific moments and/or events in time. Here are the final three pages:



In the next day or two we’ll look at a final Brainard and Padgett collaboration, and begin to catalog some of the techniques specific to Brainard’s examples, and to storyless comics in general.


8 Comments:
heh. . . I had to chuckle at "opium is the religion of the masses."
I appreciate you, Matt, and Jessica trying to come up with a new category of panel transitions. I had tried in the past to push his last category, but found myself at a loss as to how to approach it.
I met Scoot McCloud this spring and he doesn't take himself too seriously. He'd probably appreciate a new category.
I love this particular Creeley/Brainard collaboration, with its poignant mix of emotions. I think I've seen some of it someplace--probably in John Yau's catalogue on Creeley's collaborations with artists, In Company.
It really like Brainard's handwriting.
This is wonderful. Thanks for unearthing this and sharing...it reminds me of one of the outsider artists who makes his living on Ebay...he takes old yearbooks and does sheet drawings of single pages or portions of pages, and then hand-writes the creepy catchphrases or snatches of poetry they used to place under student yearbook photos in the first half of the 20th century...I can't think of his name now...but his works are very sought after, very funny, and always start a good competition at auction...if you type in "outsider artist" and look on any given day you're sure to find about five new works by him...I think his name starts with a "Z"....
I know this is a work-in-progress, but I'd like to see more analysis of the relation between text and image and what you think Brainard and Creeley are up to with the mix. Also, I'd like for you to explain how a "poetics" can include images like these, in your opinion, and how that might change what we think of as poetics.
Grant, these last are great questions, and "work in progress" definitely implies that I'd like to allow for comments like this one to redirect what I'm writing about at times.
So, though it won't exactly focus on the Creeley collab, I'll spend tomorrow talking about how image and text work differently from collaboration to collaboration in those we've looked at so far.
The second question is much bigger, but I can assure you that comics characters, pop culture in general, advertising, and so on, have all been used and/or grappled with in poetry for decades.
Take a look, for instance, at this poem by John Ashbery (one of Brainard's friends, btw).
Hey Gary--
a couple of observations. The comments are probably not from Harvard Magazine (did it use to be called Harvard Monthly?) but from the Class of 1947 25th reunion class report. Harvard publishes for each class every five years a book where alumni are asked, basically, to report where they are in life. If Creeley began in 1943, he would have been class of 1947, and would have received the 25th reunion book in 1972--perfect timing for the comic to appear in 1943.
Also, I don't really see it so much as satirical of the alumni's "posturing" or "pompous language." Rather, the whole thing seems much more poignant to me, contrasting the place in life where the writers are to where, a quarter century earlier, they had envisioned they would be, etc. To think of it as simply a "there but for the grace of god" exercise seems to deny the empathy I think can be perceived in these panels.
These are great points, Andrei. You're undoubtedly right about the origin of the text.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home